Film Review: Pulp: What Do You Do for an Encore? – 7/10

‘People think fame is a magic wand…’

There has already been one documentary about Pulp in the shape of 2014’s A Film About Life, Death & Supermarkets, and while I enjoyed that doc immensely, I don’t think it got to the heart of what makes Pulp so beloved. And so to 2026, director Garth Jennings and What Do You Do for an Encore?, a second documentary that perhaps comes closer to achieving its objective than the first one but still doesn’t quite manage it…

Jennings’ well-made documentary attempts to dovetail a traditional rise and fall narrative with a document of the band’s recent reunion tour, culminating in concert footage pulled from their recent show at the O2 – their biggest ever arena show. The problem here is that by attempting to do two things at once, Jennings ends up falling between two stools.

Any longtime fans expecting an exhaustive chronicle of the band’s gradual rise from barely heard indie nobodies to Glastonbury headliners will be disappointed. Instead, we get a whistlestop tour through plenty of interesting and heartwarming stories but nothing that is revelatory. The ace in the hole is that the doc is narrated by Jarvis himself and his sheer force of personality imbues even the most familiar moments with a wit and warmth that keeps things interesting. The archive footage, whilst frustratingly sparse, is also fantastic, and all the live footage, whether old or new, is truly joyous to behold. As someone lucky enough to have caught Pulp a few times since their most recent reunion, I can confirm that Jennings does a good job in capturing the joyous energy of those shows, even though it would have been nice to see some footage from the rest of the tour.

What Do You Do for an Encore? is well-intentioned and smartly put together, and it was genuinely a pleasure to spend 90 minutes in its company, but, ironically for a film with the word ‘encore’ in the title, it left me wanting more.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *